I don't really like groups that make the same statement over and over again. It's good, but kind of predictable.
You guys are both saying the same thing. The only reason you're arguing is because you're using different words.
I feel really fortunate that I've been given a lot of roles that were very different from each other. For me, variety is the key. I don't want to play the same thing over and over again.
Publishing can be a cliquish and incestuous business; it is not uncommon for writers from the same agencies and publishers to review each other.